Absolutely love this place ! They have such a unique, beautiful items that are perfect for a fun event. Felicia and Sammie are awesome stylists.

I dislike wearing costumes and creating them on my own. The experience with Sammie and costume closet was great. The various outfit options were robust and with support from a stylist, we had a fun time picking the right combination of outfit elements for my night out. Also I like that the clothing and accessories are thoughtfully chosen and good quality. And of course, reasonable prices makes it even sweeter. I will be back!!

Always fantastic customer service, and perfect outfits. Also makes for a great date!

Cool clothes. Cool people.

Awesome costumes, lovely people

Love love this place. It’s the ultimate costume destination for any party needs in nyc and beyond!

Unbelievable place that makes your costume dreams come true! I was in a loving hands of Sammie who made my first experience smooth, fun and sooo encouraging to follow my curiosity! 🥰🥰🥰 Love!

My visit with Sammie was so fun she's an angel and found just the right outfit for my friends wedding!! A++ will be back!

Seamless experience from booking consult, picking up modified costume, and return. Super fun time picking out options. Shout out to Felicia for custom dyeing my wig with glitter lightning bolts! So Cool - “The Disco Bride of Frankenstein” made it on TV 🙂 Thank you costume closet! 🤩

The BEST way to dress to impress for a special event. I came into the Costume Closet at the last minute before a creative Gala feeling "meh" about my outfit and looking for an upgrade. Felicia styled me head to toe, and I left with a dress + accessories that I felt incredible in - all for under $100 to rent. The owners are the sweetest, and I can't wait to further explore their collection again in the future!

Found this little gem and it has changed the way I prepare for Halloween. I was pleasantly surprised at the selection and the unique apparel. They have everything you can think of in terms of clothing and accessories. I had a very nice experience, the stylists were very helpful and enthusiastic. I recommend trying Costume Closet, especially if you have an opportunity to dress up and you don't want to go broke. Felicia and her helpers are on to something!

Costume party success! From our styling session to the rental return, Felicia was a delight to work with. Her styling savvy helped us construct the perfect looks and the amazing collection includes some real works of wearable art. I loved being a silver wolf! Got sooooo many compliments too ☺️

My Seminary was holding a prom (!) with a theme of none other than indulgence, so it felt only proper to get an indulgent, fun outfit! Coming in and getting styled by Felicia was super fun - like coming in and playing dress up! She helped me to put this together - I loved it, and also loved that I could just rent and return everything. I love supporting small, creative, sustainable businesses - would highly recommend!!

OMG this was amazing! I went to the Costume Closet looking for something different for an LGBT Purim party. I had some vague ideas which morphed pretty quickly into some very different but absolutely fabulous concrete pieces that together created exactly the look I was looking for. When we had all the clothes picked out I looked in the mirror and said "this needs a steampunk hat. Do you have anything like that?" And sure enough, a steampunk mask that worked perfectly with the whole thing turned up. The entire process was a pleasure. I was unsure what to expect and in the end it ended up being fun, easy, and SO worthwhile. I look forward to my next opportunity to work with Nick and Felicia.

Wow. This place is wild! I made an appointment with Felicia and she styled me an incredible outfit for a costume party. It’s hard finding amazing and fun clothing for men and there were so many cool options. Ended up buying one of the necklaces and I get compliments on it ALL THE TIME. I will be back soon!